Key Takeaways:

• The 10-Day Rule: If you don't have a qualified application within 10 days, your price is likely too high for the current market.
• The High Cost of Vacancy: One month of vacancy costs more than a $200/month price reduction over a full year.
• Search Filter Psychology: Price your property just below "round numbers" (e.g., $2,495 vs. $2,500) to appear in more search results.

‍

Struggling to find tenants? Unsure if your rental price is right? You're not alone. Pricing a rental property correctly is one of the most challenging—and costly—decisions property owners face. This guide provides proven strategies to determine the optimal rental price and minimize vacancy time.

How much does vacancy actually cost landlords?

Before diving into pricing strategies, understand the financial impact of a property sitting empty.

Many owners hesitate to lower their price, fearing they are "losing money." In reality, the most expensive mistake you can make is letting a property sit empty. Mathematically, it is almost always more profitable to list your property at a competitive price immediately than to "test the market" with a high price and suffer weeks of lost rent.

‍

The Math: Price Cut vs. Vacancy Loss

If you spend four extra weeks looking for an extra $100 in rent, you aren't gaining $100/mo—you are losing the $2,500 that could have been in your bank account during that month. It will take 25 months (over 2 years) of collecting that extra $100/month just to break even on the cost of one month of vacancy.

‍

How much should I rent my property for? 

To determine the most accurate starting price, you must analyze three core data points:

• Real-time Comps: Look at active listings (not just historical ones) for properties with similar square footage and bedroom/bathroom counts within a 0.5-mile radius. However, check how long they have been on the market:
  
  • Properties listed for less than 10 days show current market demand.
  • Properties sitting for 30+ days are likely overpriced and should not be used as benchmarks. If you only see stale active listings (30+ days old), this signals an oversupplied or softening market—price below these listings, not at them.
  • Recently leased properties (within the past 30 days) are the most accurate data points because they show what renters actually paid, not just what landlords hoped to get.
• Hyper-local Amenities: Adjust the price based on high-value features like in-unit laundry, private outdoor space, parking availability, recent renovations, central AC, and modern appliances like dishwashers.
• Search Filter Psychology: Price your home strategically to fall within common search buckets (e.g., pricing at $2,495 instead of $2,505 to appear in "Under $2,500" filters).

‍

The showing benchmark: When should I adjust my rental listing price? 

We recommend monitoring your listing daily. If your property isn't hitting these performance metrics, it is likely overpriced for the current market:

1. The Showing Benchmark: You should ideally see 2 to 3 showings per week. 
   
   1. If you have high views but no showing requests, the price is the primary deterrent.
   2. If you have low views overall, there is a listing quality (e.g., photo quality) or listing platform reach issue.
2. The 7-10 Day Window: If you haven’t received a qualified application within the first 10 days, the market is signaling that your price is out of sync with current demand. You should receive at least 1 application for every 3 to 4 showings.

We suggest adjusting your price if your property is seeing:

• Fewer than 2 showings per week
• No qualified applications within 10 days of listing
• Sudden market shifts (new apartment complexes opening nearby)
• Seasonal demand changes
• Comparable properties leasing faster at lower prices

It's better to adjust early and often than to hold firm on an overpriced property.

‍

Rental Marketing Strategies: How to Fill Vacancies Fast

Many homeowners start by asking, "How do I rent my house out?" while overlooking the most critical factor: online conversion. Online visibility is the single most important factor in modern leasing. According to Zillow's 2025 Rental Consumer Housing Trends Report., the typical renter only does one in-person tour, suggesting most of the search is conducted online. To maximize your chances and create a high performing listing:

Professional Photography is Non-Negotiable

Properties with professional photos lease 1.7x faster according to our internal data . Ensure your listing includes:

• At least one photo per room (wide-angle).
• Exterior shots of the building and common areas.
• Clear photos of amenities (parking, laundry, dishwasher).
• Virtual Tours: Listings with 3D or video tours receive more engagement, 25% of renters say it is essential according to Zillow

Write "Search-Optimized" Descriptions

• Write Detailed Descriptions: Include specific details that answer common questions and keywords that renters actually type into search bars
  
  • Exact square footage, bedroom/bathroom count
  • Laundry situation (in-unit, shared, hookups available)
  • Parking (garage, driveway, street, permit required)
  • Utilities (what's included, what tenant pays)
  • Pet policy (allowed, restrictions, fees)
  • Lease terms and move-in requirements
• Maximize Online Distribution: Today's renters search on multiple platforms. Your listing should appear on Zillow, Trulia, and more.

How Doorstead Helps You Price and Fill Vacancies Faster

Our Autopilot Engine: Data-Driven Pricing

Instead of manually tracking comparables and guessing at adjustments, our proprietary algorithm analyzes millions of data points daily from active listings and recent leases. We factor in seasonal shifts, real-time inventory levels, and hyper-local demand to ensure your price is always Goldilocks territory—not so high it sits empty, and not so low you leave money on the table.

Properties priced according to our recommendations find tenants in a median of 27 days and lease 57% faster than those that don't follow our guidance. 

While our pricing engine can automatically update your rental price to minimize vacancy at the highest rent price–creating a truly hands-off experience–owners have final say on the rental price and can always opt out or adjust the price themselves. We want owners to feel like they have full control over how their property gets leased. 

Proactive Performance Monitoring

We don't wait for you to notice problems. Our technology provides:

• Automated Triggers: If a property falls below our performance benchmarks (based on leasing data collected from over five years of leasing thousands of properties), our system triggers an immediate strategy review.
• Actionable Insights: You receive proactive recommendations on when to adjust price or improve listing quality based on how your property is performing as these benchmarks. 

You stay ahead of the market instead of reacting too late.

Maximum Visibility Through Strategic Distribution

We take the marketing burden off your plate entirely by providing:

• Professional Media: We coordinate free professional photography and optional 3D virtual tours to ensure your property stands out in crowded search results.
• Strategic Distribution: We leverage direct API integrations with Zillow, Trulia, and more  to ensure your listing is promoted instantly across the entire rental ecosystem.
• Elite Screening: Our team handles the heavy lifting of background checks, income verification, and rental history with our proprietary application flow. Find out more here
• Pre-leasing: For owners who want to get a head start on finding a tenant while their property is still occupied, Doorstead offers pre-leasing options. As long as you provide property photos, details, and consent from current occupants, we can list and show your property while it's still occupied. This allows us to start generating interest and collecting applications even before your property is vacant, further reducing the time it takes to find a qualified tenant. Please note that for pre-leasing, owners will need to provide their own property photos, as we cannot take photos until the property is vacant.